From BLOGDIAL, “The answer comes before the question” January 13th, 2009
Imagine this scenario. Someone somewhere sets up a Web 2.0 site that features photos of bad police and other officials, or those mysterious agent provocateurs that have been plaguing the useless demonstrations around the world. Imagine that the software behind this site (which could be connected to iPhoto 09) identifies all the bad people and exposes them to the public, nullifying all acts of political infiltration over night. Anyone setting up any sort of anti-state gathering or demonstration or action could, with a gauntlet of workers armed with iphones, vet every demonstrator as they turned up to weed out all the infiltrators, collaborators and provocateurs.
I guarantee you that this will happen, and not only that, but that someone is going to put into a copy of iPhoto 09, a huge archive of photos from demonstrations and political meetings going back decades to pick out the bad guys.
This explosion and convergence of technologies is a double edged sword, and since there are more of us than there are of them, it will be the case that all this technology and the networks that join them together will result in something totally unexpected; the tools may turn around and bite the state in the ass in an unexpected way. The very nature of networks says that this will happen; the population by virtue of its vast networked numbers can overpower any government in a scenario where the network is the power.
We are not powerless like the slaves in the Soviet Union were. We have fantastic tools, all of them free, right in our hands. Those tools, by the act of using them, change the game entirely, and the more the state pushes against the mass, the more dense and impenetrable it becomes.
This is a war that they cannot ever win.
Now look at the attached video, uploaded to YouTube by noshockdoc on Nov 11, 2011.If these people had any sense, they would have already set up this web service as I described in 2009.
Using Augmented Reality ID:
They could check each ‘protestor’ against the online database of Agent Provocateurs and police officers to make sure that they had not been infiltrated.
Of course, anyone who is that smart is not interested in demonstrating in the first place, but we will leave that aside for now.
The point is, these young and very foolish people are behaving as if it is 1960 and not 2011. As I have said before, again and again, the age of demonstrations is over. The shape of them, how they play out, move, surge and flow is well understood. There can be no surprises with them. Nothing comes of them, no matter how large they are, as we saw with the StopWar demonstrations before the destruction of Iraq.
The problem these people have is that if they were intelligent enough to know this, they would not be demonstrating, and would be well on the way to formulating a strategy that would actually give them what they want. Their problem, clearly, is a toxic mix of a lack of intelligence and experience.
They do not know exactly what they hope to achieve with these acts, they have no discrete goals or deliverables, they have no means of creating a new strategy because they lack the mental capacity to formulate one; in other words, they are a completely lost cause.
One thing that is coming out of this is interesting however.
Because everyone has a camera at these demonstrations, it might come to pass that the light bulb switches on over the head of some computer science student as she realizes that it should be possible to create what I describe in the post above.
There are literally dozens of cameras in this clip; surely someone somewhere must be thinking that there is a use that can be put to the footage to help weed out the provocateurs. Who knows?
What we can say with a high level of certainty is that these students are going to achieve nothing by marching in the street. Everything they are planning, even if it is not known about in advance by surveillance is easily counterable because marching and demonstrating is a ‘dead tactic’ that the State has a perfect understanding of.
All of this is a complete distraction of course; even this very post has distracted me from doing something else productive.
Demonstrations are ‘Yellow Ribbon Thinking’:
they divert energy from useful acts and thinking, and prevent or delay permanent solutions from emerging.